Cartoon illustration of an abandoned haunted house at night with a glowing podcast studio visible through a cobweb-covered window, representing the Halloween episode of Podcast Permission Slip about what should really scare podcasters

22: What Should Really Scare Podcasters (A Halloween Episode)

🎧 Prefer to listen? Click here to listen to this episode on your favorite podcast player.

It’s almost Halloween and I want to talk about something that should genuinely scare you, and it’s not your tech setup or navigating the social media algorithms. It’s something much more real! 

I came across a post recently from someone I’ve referenced on the show before. I know I was a little hard on Gary Vaynerchuk in my More More More episode, but on this one I think he nailed it. He was talking about how regret should be the thing we actually fear.

He’s talking about waking up at 70, 80, 90 and looking back at your life, the things you didn’t do, the life you didn’t live because you were scared of what someone else might think. Being 48 at the time of recording this, that got me thinking because life isn’t slowing down and the last feeling I want to experience is at this stage of my life is regret.

Dream BIG

I also happen to be reading a book right now by an author who’s new to me, Bob Goff. The book is called Dream Big, and shout out to my friend Tracy for introducing me to his work because I’d never heard of him before. I’ve picked up a couple of his books and I’m really looking forward to getting into them all.

What he’s talking about in Dream Big is knowing what you want, why you want it, and what you’re going to do about it. That’s the long and short of it. And it lit a fire under me to talk about this topic. I think it could help anyone regardless of what it is that you’re dreaming to do.

What I’ve Seen With Regret in the Podcasting Space

We’ve been working with podcasters for almost 12 years now, and I can honestly say that not once have I ever spoken with anyone who regretted starting their podcast. Maybe they didn’t achieve what they wanted to with their show, or they stopped of any reason which is understandable, but even the ones whose shows didn’t work out the way they planned, or who stopped and never came back to it. Not one person has ever said “I wish I hadn’t done that.”

But I’ve heard from plenty of people, more than I can count on both hands, who have told me they regret never starting. And I’ve also talked to people who regret stopping. People who got some real momentum behind their show years ago, enjoyed the process, and then for whatever reason walked away. You could just hear it in their voice when they tell you where they might be if they’d kept going.

*note: according to the latest PodMatch Industry Report, it takes releasing 100 episodes before podcasters see results, yet 93.50% quit before reaching this point!

I wonder how I’d feel right now if I hadn’t decided to start this show on a whim the week before Christmas of 2025. I launched it in 6 days, pushed past all the little voices in my head, the imposter syndrome, the “I’m too busy,” the “would people even want to listen to this?” and just got it out there. Because I know that’s often the hardest part.

Don’t Wait to Be Ready

If anyone has told you that starting a podcast is going to take many weeks, months, or even up to a year of planning, please don’t listen to that. I’ve seen articles shared by podcast professionals with titles suggesting that if you’re not planning for 6 months to a year that you shouldn’t even bother. I don’t think that’s the right advice (and I don’t think I could ever be convinced of that). I’m more of a “jump and the parachute will open” type of person, and I’ve seen that approach work over and over again.

Our newest client is a perfect example of this. Maggie Raines hosts Campfire Faith with Maggie and Friends, and she signed her agreement with us on August 20th of this year. Her show was live on all the major platforms by August 27th – yes, in just 7 days flat! 

And she did this before she had her social media accounts set up for the podcast. No Facebook page for the show yet, no dedicated email, nothing. She just said let’s get it out there and figured the rest out in the days that followed.

What happened next is worth sharing. Before she had any of that set up, she had hundreds of downloads on her first episode, and it wasn’t from ads or algorithm hacking. It was from one post by her husband Matt sharing her show with his network, a network built over 23 years as a youth camp leader. One organic share from someone who believed in her and the show was off to the races.

So don’t sleep on organic promotion! You don’t have to be gaming social media algorithms or hacking Apple Podcasts to get your podcast into the ears of people who want to hear what you have to say.

Maggie also recorded an episode early in her show called “Faith Over Fear: Trusting God When You’re Scared to Move Forward”, about going back to nursing school in her 40s and what she overcame to do it. Whether it’s nursing school or hitting record for the first time on your podcast, the principle is really the same….

And the great news is that Maggie has agreed to come on this show as a guest for the very next episode in November, so you’ll get to hear her story in her own words very soon!

Your Permission Slip

I know that podcasting can be intimidating. It can be a bit unnerving to press record and put something out to the world for anyone to listen to. Trust me, I know that just as much as anyone. 

But if this episode helps you push past the fear, whether it’s to start your podcast, launch your business, write that book, run that marathon, go on that dream trip, or whatever it may be that you’ve been putting off, then I’m very glad you tuned in.

No regrets! 

If you think this episode could help someone, please share it with anyone you think could benefit from it. You can always reach me at matt@podassist.com or find me on Facebook and LinkedIn.

Remember, it’s YOUR show and there are NO RULES – and Happy Halloween! 🎃👻

Ready to launch your podcast in as little as TWO weeks, stress-free? Or need help with your current show? Book a no-obligation call with me at https://calendly.com/mattpodassist.

 

LINKS:

New Client Launch: Maggie Raines of CampFire Faith with Maggie & Friends (Blog Post)

Faith Over Fear (Campfire Faith Episode)

Dream Big by Bob Goff 

18: More, More, More: The “Expert” Advice I’m Not Following